Meta: Supernatural "Big Secret" Theory

All, right, this is an utter dog's breakfast in terms of organization, but I'm posting it anyway.

I have had this theory developing since watching the episode "Home" and John's 'I have to know for sure' line. The very first inklings may have come from the Pilot episode.

I avoid spoilers like the plague, this is strictly theory based on observations and my subjective viewpoint. And no doubt other people have developed really similar theories. I haven't seen any, but I obviously haven't read everything because it'd like trying to keep up with an exploding fractal bomb, reading all the fan-produced stuff for Supernatural.

Contains Spoilers for everything aired to this date in North America.

( Long-winded confusing theory behind cut )

So anyways, there it is, long, confusing and rambling. Please tell me how wrong I am and why. Logical and referenced reasons are vastly preferrable to personal attacks. :-)

Oh and PLEASE, NO SPOILERS FOR UNAIRED EPISODES!!!!!

Meta: Supernatural "Big Secret" Theory

All, right, this is an utter dog's breakfast in terms of organization, but I'm posting it anyway.

I have had this theory developing since watching the episode "Home" and John's 'I have to know for sure' line. The very first inklings may have come from the Pilot episode.

I avoid spoilers like the plague, this is strictly theory based on observations and my subjective viewpoint. And no doubt other people have developed really similar theories. I haven't seen any, but I obviously haven't read everything because it'd like trying to keep up with an exploding fractal bomb, reading all the fan-produced stuff for Supernatural.

Contains Spoilers for everything aired to this date in North America.

( Long-winded confusing theory behind cut )

So anyways, there it is, long, confusing and rambling. Please tell me how wrong I am and why. Logical and referenced reasons are vastly preferrable to personal attacks. :-)

Oh and PLEASE, NO SPOILERS FOR UNAIRED EPISODES!!!!!